logo Sign In

Post #282300

Author
dumb_kid
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 REVISITED ADYWAN *1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/282300/action/topic#282300
Date created
14-Apr-2007, 1:40 AM
Adywan,

Pretty impressive stuff... the Tie/Falcon Chase is really good.... no complaints at all from me

-----

And now for some constructive criticism on the Vader/Ben duel....

The new music is an interesting choice which to be honest I don't know if I care for it or not, but even so when Han, Luke, Leia are talking it should be slightly quieter... their dialog is getting drowned out.

New Sabers are great!

The transition from new music to old music (when Ben dies) is a little jarring... as is Luke's "No!" (was it shortened or sped up?)

It seems that the shoot out was sped up a bit to make it "faster, more intense!" The only problem is that it now looks like an old Chaplin movie.... everyone is moving a bit too quickly and it looks un-natural... especially the smoke from the blasters

---

Just my $0.02
As always you really do impress with your tweaks and add-ons... keep up the great work