Yub Nub, I think it should count as vocalized. That one is a true classic. Craig Kilborn preformed an acustic version of it on his show some years ago, it was pretty funny. Replacing that song may have been the one aspect of the SE I truly enjoyed, I found the new music much more moving and fitting for the end of the trilogy. It is sad but happy at once, kind of like a sigh of relief and deep breath taken at the end of a great long winded struggle, finally a chance to relax... and mourn the loss of our comrades.

I didn't mind the vocalized music of the PT, it definately had flaws far beyond that to take the blame. I really liked Duel of the Fates, it was a great and very energetic piece. I think ROTS may have gone a little overboard with it though. Some spots had very dramatic music while the stuff going on on screen was utter lameness, I feel this gives the film a slightly comic effect, which I am pretty sure is not what they were aiming for.