Originally posted by: TheCassidy

Calling someone's hard work garbage is being a dick.

And you've never critiqued a movie or a book or a piece of music? Everything is wonderful? You're either a sycophant or a hypocrite.

I praised Adywan's technical ability. I just don't care for the movie he chose to work on or the manner in which he's doing it and I stand behind that totally. Making creatures blink from a technical stand point is impressive. But in a practical sense, it doesn't serve the movie. Why replace the shot of the Falcon going into hyperspace for the first time? It's a powerful dramatic moment that now looks amateurish.

I didn't threaten him. I passed along an opinion. It wasn't an attack, and it wasn't meant as one. Any artist must learn to deal with criticism and I think he has. He's not the one insulting me and he seemed to have a bit of sense of humor about it. That's good.

Neil