You could put a blue filter over every scene in the trilogy for all I care. That doesn't mean I have to watch it. That also doesn't mean I have to criticize your desire to want to do it, either. I might criticize the logic or merit of it, but as far as I'm concerned, you can do whatever you want.

If Neil doesn't like fan edits, that's fine. He doesn't have to watch them, either, though, if he doesn't want to. He has every right to criticize the ideas behind them, but if he doesn't like any of the ideas, none of the edits you make will please him, anyway. I know he's a big fan of the original theatrical releases, so he just doesn't like tinkering done to what he sees as perfect (or at least fine) already. And there is a good argument for that. But that argument pretty much negates something that a lot (the majority?) of people here think is fun.

Neil, there is a thread under "Suggestions and Ideas" that I started a while back that you might want to sound-off on. This site is about getting nice releases of the originals, so maybe your opinions about the merits of what this site has become might be more appropriate there.

http://www.originaltrilogy.com/forum/messageview.cfm?catid=5&threadid=7489