I agree with Sluggo. Don't let this guy get you down. He makes it sound like once you release this it will become the definitive Star Wars movie (And while that would be awesome for any editor on this board, it probably isn't going to happen). If he is so upset about this one, why isn't he upset about every single fan edit out there? Sure, I've thought about it, and on a board where people are striving to get a good release of the original trilogy, they are excited about a Special Updated Edition with all new effects, it may seem strange, but who cares? It looks good. This seems to be a "Special Edition Done Right". Instead of an orgy of all-new special effects, it fixes the problems with the movie.
You shouldn't stop making this. A lot of stuff from here ends up on Ebay, just ask Jambe Davdar, or anyone who's ever release a Holiday Special disk. They all seem fine. Besides, I think it's safe to say we all legally own a copy of Star Wars (I have at least seven). Plus, some members here have patrolled ebay for people selling other edits and reported them. I think you'd ok.