logo Sign In

Post #269802

Author
Batman Beyond
Parent topic
***The ADigitalMan non-Star Wars DVD Info and Feedback Thread***
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/269802/action/topic#269802
Date created
5-Feb-2007, 7:30 AM
I have just seen SUPERMAN REDEEMED. I must say, this re-edit is immensly impressive. Really, this is Superman III for me.

However, I a question: Do all owners of REDEEMED see what I see? Which is, the beggining of the film is out of sync. Perry, that lottery girl and Lois talk out of sync, and after a time, the sync is fine. Do all people have this prob?

Also, three complaints - very minor, though. I believe there were three scenes that could've been used but weren't. 1) The jail scene from IV. It could've been used to a minimal use, to show what happened to Lex after II, before the Otis scene. Anyway, no biggie. 2)I thought Superman going evil immediately after the scratch, was a bit too quick. The scene in IV with a sick Clark could've been used, to also show Lois showing some support. Of course, next we see evil Superman. That scene from IV could've been a good bridge, IMO - 3) The Pisa ending - I always loved that II ended in such a funny note. I wish this film ended that way, too. But no biggie here, too.

Anyway, I want to say, a dream has come true! Now, a Christopher Reeve Trilogy is a reality. Great, great re-edit.

4 out of 5 stars, overall.