Originally posted by: Trooperman
That's pretty much the only reason I would do it- to satisfy these people. Because it would become a whole different movie (and a weaker one). The whole point was that I couldn't create a good, logical movie out of Ep. II with the original source material.
I understand the trepidation regarding the new ADR, but lets see if it's still bothering some people after it's finished and my new takes are mixed back in. Who knows- you might be surprised...
Originally posted by: andy_k_250
I would say it's up to you. I think that if you don't though, someone else will probably try further down the line.
I would say it's up to you. I think that if you don't though, someone else will probably try further down the line.
That's pretty much the only reason I would do it- to satisfy these people. Because it would become a whole different movie (and a weaker one). The whole point was that I couldn't create a good, logical movie out of Ep. II with the original source material.
I understand the trepidation regarding the new ADR, but lets see if it's still bothering some people after it's finished and my new takes are mixed back in. Who knows- you might be surprised...
I wouldn't worry about trying to satisfy them. No matter what you do there will always be people that have a different opinion about any edit. After all.. It is YOUR vision so do it the way that satisfies you. If they don't like the new ADR then so be it but at least you won't have had to compromise on your original idea to try and please everyone. If they don't like the new Anakin voice tuff cuz there will be plenty that do. After all ANH used the same voice actor for 3 characters (commander on Tantive 4, barkeep & Dodonna) and is glaringy a dubbed voice but i haven't seen many ( if a any) people complain about that.
I for one can't wait for this release.
