Okay, I can't speak for either of those games, but if Adam Sessler, a man who hates all things Final Fantasy, liked FF12 (even if it has different mechanics than the old games) I think it might be worth a shot.

Originally posted by: skyjedi2005
phantom hourglass that is supposed to come out for the ds in the near future is supposed to be a sequel to the wind waker. I wonder if it will be a good game?

if the whole game times you like majora's mask then it will suck.

Every publication I've seen has loved the new mechanics, and if a timed gameplay mechanic worked in Majora's Mask, why wouldn't it also work in Phantom Hourglass?

I also think it is entirely stupid that they mirrored twilight princess for the Wii. and I hate the gimmicky controller so I'll just get the gamecube version and it will be like playing a zelda as usual

This is ridiculous, dude. The Wii version plays excellent. The controller doesn't feel gimmicky at all, and the only complaint I have is a faint desire to be able to swing my sword with the press of a button. Otherwise, TP on the Wii rules. Aiming the bow with the Wiimote is made of awesome.

Nintendo can never make a better Zelda than a link to the past...Just like they cannot possibly make a better metroid than super metroid or a better mario than mario 64.

Um... They've already made a better Metroid than Super Metroid. It's called Metroid Fusion. And Mario 64 is a great game, but there's no way it's better than SMB3 or Super Mario World.

They actually used the game engine on quest 64 what a waste. I will never forgive nintendo for that.

Wait, wait, THQ publishes a crappy Imagineer developed RPG, and this is somehow Nintendo's fault?