logo Sign In

Post #266163

Author
ricarleite
Parent topic
Ep 3 death star !
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/266163/action/topic#266163
Date created
16-Jan-2007, 3:39 PM
This is a huge inconsistence on the saga, and all the explanations to it are, for me, merely FANON (well, there are a lot of those to correct plot holes GL left behind).

Unless that scene was set some years before ANH it makes no sense at all, and is thrown there (along with Moff Tarkin) just to please fans with something that looks like it's from the OT (and just for a few seconds!!). BUT since the baby delivery scene is shown AFTER that scene, and GL is no Tarantino and dosen't move foward and back in time on his films, we are to assume that the Death Star was being constructed for some time before the events on ROTS, maybe at the end of AOTC. So it took something like 22 years to build the first one, and 4 years to partially build the second one. Plot hole? To me, yes.