logo Sign In

Post #265884

Author
CO
Parent topic
Seeing the Saga in order - a review by a first-time viewer....
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/265884/action/topic#265884
Date created
15-Jan-2007, 1:03 PM
You are right that we all knew the suprises going in, and maybe I am taking it a bit far, but the only way I thought the PT would succeed, would be a true backstory. One that is NOT supposed to be watched before OT, and everything that is made in it is written that you have seen the OT first.

The end of ROTS is a perfect example of putting in plot points to appease the OT fans. If Lucas wanted to make a compelling 1-6 story, Anakin should have been left burning on Mustafar, and never seen again til he breaks down the door in ANH at the beginning. That way the whole OT you are watching it wondering who this Vader guy, holy shit, it is Anakin! He survived!!! Now there would have to be some dialogue changes in ANH by Kenobi to compliment the linear storytelling, but if Lucas truly wanted the story to be watched in 1-6 fashion, the ending of ROTS would be totally different.

Also, there are things in the PT just to appease the OT fans, cameos by Jabba, the jawas, and the tuskens in the pod race which are pointless. Owen would have had a much different role had it been written 1-6, but Lucas had to find a way to get him in so he makes him fucking own C3PO 20 years before buying him unknowingly again?

The only thing that Lucas was concerned about in the PT was Anakins character arc, and that is the only thing that he wants to succeed in the 1-6 storytelling now, as you see this little boy who is a good kid go down a dark rode to become Darth Vader and then redeem himself in ROTJ at the end of the movie. Now that is a cool story, the problem is the fucking OT only really covers that story at the end of ESB, and the last hour ROTJ! So you basically have most of ANH, half of ESB, and half of ROTJ that don't deal with Anakins character arc.