You would think the PT would be better if he made it first, but I don't think that would be the case. It would be if it was anyone else other than George Lucas.

I think he would make them all by the seat of his pants and then release edition after edition, trying to fix what he should have done right from the start.

The PT was a no brainer. The OT pretty much dictated what had to happen. Lucas did the exact opposite of what he should have done and look what happened....

So no...it wouldn't be better!!!