LOL, that Simon critic was a trip. Where ever this guy is from ( He sounded a bit German or Soviet ) He was totally unqualified to critique ROTJ. I think Ebert summed it up pretty good sayingText "I don't know what he did as a child". If he grew up in Europe or the Soviet Union, he didn't spend it watching movies. Simon looks to have been heavily into books and/or the Opera in his youth. Something which would have been very common to him over seas as a kid.