logo Sign In

Post #262095

Author
Gaffer Tape
Parent topic
Should Yoda Have Been Part of the "Conspiracy"?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/262095/action/topic#262095
Date created
19-Dec-2006, 4:29 PM
I was watching ESB today, and I suddenly had a thought about Yoda's nature in this movie as opposed to the prequel trilogy (surprised)? As everyone knows, Yoda tried to reject Luke for being impatient and being too old and still seemed unsure even at the behest of Luke and Ben even though Yoda is well aware that Luke is one of the last hopes for the galaxy and, as we later learn from ROTS, that he was present at Luke's birth and personally responsible for sending Luke to Tatooine in anticipation of his later role. Does that make any sense? I suppose the easiest theory would be that Yoda was simply continuing his test of Luke, but if that were the case, why would Ben need to intervene on Luke's behalf?

Thinking about this, I came to the opinion that it would have made more sense if Yoda had not been around during the last parts of ROTS. That he had been beaten and watched all the Jedi been killed, and, at that point, he had pretty much given up on everything and decided to go to Dagobah not only to hide but to separate himself from the evil in the rest of the galaxy. And it was solely Obi-Wan's idea and implentation to separate the twins and watch over Luke because he still had a glimmer of hope. But after he had to sacrifice himself, Yoda, still skeptical as it seems in ESB, agreed to train Luke. That's the impression I get from watching ESB (and ROTJ), that it was Obi-Wan who was in charge of such things. Yoda's involvement in regards to Luke, Leia, and even Anakin for that matter, was never mentioned in the OT, and, based on what we saw of him, it doesn't seem like there would have been that much he did in regards to the twins.

Any thoughts?