logo Sign In

Post #260787

Author
JediSage
Parent topic
A Date Which Will Live...in Infamy
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/260787/action/topic#260787
Date created
8-Dec-2006, 3:52 PM
From "Criticism of Noam Chomsky's Politics" wiki:

"In The End of Faith, Sam Harris criticizes the ethical propositions that lead Chomsky to direct his rhetoric towards the United States foreign policy (as opposed to the tenets of radical Islam):

Nothing in Chomsky's account acknowledges the difference between intending to kill a child, because of the effect you hope to produce on its parents (we call this "terrorism"), and inadvertently killing a child in an attempt to capture or kill an avowed child murderer (we call this "collateral damage"). In both cases a child has died, and in both cases it is a tragedy. But the ethical status of the perpetrators, be they individuals or states, cold not be more distinct... For [Chomsky], intentions do not seem to matter. Body count is all."

Yeah, I see the resemblence.