Originally posted by: Fang Zei
First of all, your argument doesn't really apply to the Star Wars movies. Maybe the original film from 1977, but in that case Lucas was still the director and knew the special effects we see in the SE were not even remotely possible at the time. The motion control system developed by John Dykstra was revolutionary, and those extra six months the production was afforded to complete special effects with said motion control system turned into a small miracle. What does Lucas do? He treats it like it means nothing by replacing many of the shots with cgi, barely half-decent cgi for 1997, I might add.
As for the sequels, guess what? Lucas had complete control in every sense over those productions. No one said he "had" to release them in 1980 and 1983, respectively. Did he advertise those movies as "must see half-finished movies?" No, he simply claimed that the movies he knew everyone was dying to see during that time were merely half finished, it just didn't occur to him to tell anyone until 2004.
No self-respecting artist publicly exhibits their work for the first time and then comes back to it year's later claiming that it was "half-finished," and I mean no artist.
So please don't spew that hogwash about "the studio saying it was finished." If that were true than what would you call what millions of people saw back on May 21st, 1980?
Originally posted by: JediRandy
Wrong... it's released because the studio says it to be released, not because it's "finished".... it's finished when the person who created it says it's finished... whenever that is, be it the next day or 30 years later.
Wrong... it's released because the studio says it to be released, not because it's "finished".... it's finished when the person who created it says it's finished... whenever that is, be it the next day or 30 years later.
First of all, your argument doesn't really apply to the Star Wars movies. Maybe the original film from 1977, but in that case Lucas was still the director and knew the special effects we see in the SE were not even remotely possible at the time. The motion control system developed by John Dykstra was revolutionary, and those extra six months the production was afforded to complete special effects with said motion control system turned into a small miracle. What does Lucas do? He treats it like it means nothing by replacing many of the shots with cgi, barely half-decent cgi for 1997, I might add.
As for the sequels, guess what? Lucas had complete control in every sense over those productions. No one said he "had" to release them in 1980 and 1983, respectively. Did he advertise those movies as "must see half-finished movies?" No, he simply claimed that the movies he knew everyone was dying to see during that time were merely half finished, it just didn't occur to him to tell anyone until 2004.
No self-respecting artist publicly exhibits their work for the first time and then comes back to it year's later claiming that it was "half-finished," and I mean no artist.
So please don't spew that hogwash about "the studio saying it was finished." If that were true than what would you call what millions of people saw back on May 21st, 1980?
So just because it was seen publically makes it "finished"? The second that movie played on a screen its done and no longer available to be worked on further? Bullshit. Your arguement is the same crap that people drop when they act like the movies are "theirs".
Furthermore, ESB and ROTJ (and the PT) are distributed by Fox.... Fox is paying for that and still give a solid date that they want/need the movie for distrobution... GL funding the making of the films means nothing to Fox. Fox is still putting money into the movies.