logo Sign In

Post #258959

Author
Trooperman
Parent topic
Episode II: Shroud of the Dark Side (the TM edit) (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/258959/action/topic#258959
Date created
28-Nov-2006, 9:35 PM
Thank you to all who commented on the voice- I'm trying out some new techniques/filters, so what you heard is definitely not final yet. Bespinsec, who's an actual audio engineer, very kindly PMd me with advice on this. We want to bring that warm, "analogue" quality to these modern digital recordings, and still keep the low end of Anakin's voice (so it isn't shrill or tinny). Otherwise it's not going to work too well.

Originally posted by: Marvolo
The problem with releasing an unfinished product is people ( not refering to the members of this site) will hear about the edit and download the rough cut and not like the flaws. So in turn they will not download the updated version, thinking it not worth the time, and then they will post bad reviews about it on websites like TF.N. I say take your time and do it right TM.

That's kind of what I'm thinking. After all this time and work, I really don't want people criticizing something that isn't even finished- it would really make me sad. Especially when the end is just a couple months away. The new voices and the believability of the new ADR will make or break this film, and I've GOT to get it right before people see it. Every person that saw an unfinished cut of this would not get the effect of seeing this film the way I want them to see it for the first time- their initial impression would be incorrect.

TM will heed whatever feedback he gets and fix any technical errors before the DL release. Right now I am sure he just wants to be done with it more than any of us want to see it.


Bingo I'll take my break in between single-layer and dual-layer releases. Not that I didn't really enjoy editing this movie and brainstorming ideas, but right now, I just want to finish it and pick up life where I left off...