Originally posted by: BeeJay
Nobody, it might be getting a bit off-topic. But I might like to have an explanation of what you mean by inconsistent. Emotions of turmoil can't all be the same from day to day or Star Wars movie to Star Wars movie ....emotions are like a storm, and they are always going up and down. Especially with Anakin Skywalker.
If I may, I think I feel the same way as Nobody on this one... er, in that I have the same opinion as the poster called Nobody, not... well, you know...Nobody, it might be getting a bit off-topic. But I might like to have an explanation of what you mean by inconsistent. Emotions of turmoil can't all be the same from day to day or Star Wars movie to Star Wars movie ....emotions are like a storm, and they are always going up and down. Especially with Anakin Skywalker.
Xebeche... he who talk loud, say nothing...
Who are you travellin' with?
...Nobody!
Anyway...
It's that what we see and what we hear and what we know about his future are not consistent with each other, not that Anakin's emotional state should remain the same throughout. Anakin's responses seem inconsistent with his situation. I honestly feel that his responses to his surroundings and situations seem constantly at odds with who he is and who he will become.
The first example I would give is when he first speaks after being put in the suit. He's concerned about Padme. He's distraught that she's dead. Yet this, to me, is inconsistent with his character and situation. It's also the worst made scene in the saga in every possible way.