Originally posted by: Trooperman

I now have both versions of the character of Jar-Jar. I'm considering posting two versions of a clip- one with Sluggo's version, and one with hairy_hen's version, and get your feedback.
By all means, please do!

I think I know what I'm going to go with, but I hope it won't be too jarring.

Granted I havent heard the british Jar-Jar voice yet, but I suspect that with a project of this stature that already has changed so many elements, chances are that your projected target audience will most likely be more pleasantly surprised than "jarred" by a british Jar-Jar. (which would make the film's tone even more in line with the OT). It's not like the original Jar-Jar can possible get any *more* jarring....