Originally posted by: THX
To my eyes, 11B is perfect - or at least as good as it can get (the only thing that hasn't been experimented with is making the outer "Star Wars" box outline rather than solid). All the 11s look professional to me, while all the 12s look amateur. I think this is because of the squashed top row. Differently scaled lettering is fine, but you shouldn't mess with the (ahem) aspect ratio. None of the OT logos do, not even the "Faces" ones. Not that they should be used as a reference, IMHO, since they are the SE logos.
So 11B is my choice. Ultimately, though, there is only one opinion that counts - Trooperman's.
To my eyes, 11B is perfect - or at least as good as it can get (the only thing that hasn't been experimented with is making the outer "Star Wars" box outline rather than solid). All the 11s look professional to me, while all the 12s look amateur. I think this is because of the squashed top row. Differently scaled lettering is fine, but you shouldn't mess with the (ahem) aspect ratio. None of the OT logos do, not even the "Faces" ones. Not that they should be used as a reference, IMHO, since they are the SE logos.
So 11B is my choice. Ultimately, though, there is only one opinion that counts - Trooperman's.
Glad to hear I'm not alone in loving the "11's". I totally agree with the above. My personal favourite is the slightly angled 11c.
I totally respect Trooperman's final arbitration on the matter though, the man deserves the final say for his masterpiece.
A few alternates for us infidels would be great though ;-) A style B poster with a 11b or 11c logo should look incredible.