Originally posted by: Go-Mer-Tonic

I'll grant you there were a lot of people who didn't like them. But I don't see how that makes them a "mistake" on Lucas' part.

I'm just saying that no matter what Lucas did, there would have been some fans that didn't like it. I'm not being unreasonable in that assumption am I?

What? Where did I attack the reason of your assumption, Go-Mer? Are you really this stupid or do you simply enjoy arguing about topics that nobody is arguing about?

No, Go-Mer, as far as I'm concerned, your "assumption" there is an obvious fact. Is it not obvious to you? I actually think you're being an asshole for assuming that people need to even be told that. Nobody here, that I'm aware of, is that stupid. Even if someone here were that stupid, your statement has no relevance in this thread as an argument, Go-Mer (which is what I'm trying to tell you).

We are all very much aware that there will always be the odd, strange person who has a messed-up view of reality and might actually hate something wonderful, or enjoy something that clearly sucks. In fact, you remind us of that fact with practically every post of yours.

How would you like it, Go-Mer, if I responded to each and every one your posts with, "Well, no matter what George Lucas did in the PT, there will be fans that will love it no matter what"? Would that be a good argument to your reasons for liking the trilogy? Would you have liked it if I dismissed you as crazy and insinuated your unfairness with every reply I ever gave to you?