OK, first off...
Audio: excellent! Darth sounds amazing! the EQ sounds better over all...
New DS approach: HOLY COW! Just amazing! This should have been here a long time ago! I dig the planet, I dig the scale (yeah, maybe check on those SD), I dig the music!
Of course, a few "nitpicks": you might consider reducing the number of ties in that first shot of the DS. I was blown away by the entire shot, but I didn't know where to look at first...I think the DS should be the focus.
Music: the piece when Vader says "I find your lack of faith disturbing" is freakin' awesome! chilling!
Question: did you trim a few frames from the conference scene? some shots seem shorter...?
Pic of droids going down below: finally! no more pick blob!
Again, just amazing work! I keep watching this clip over and over!
Also, if this is one of your last clips to show all of us, obviously, I'm sad.
BUT don't be afraid to bounce ideas off of us...hopefully our nitpicking has helped and not hendered your progress!