logo Sign In

Post #255122

Author
Commander Courage
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 REVISITED ADYWAN *1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/255122/action/topic#255122
Date created
6-Nov-2006, 4:51 PM
Adywan: AMAZING. In my opinion if you're going to do a fan edit, it needs to be done professionally. If there's anything that isn't seemless or takes you out of the movie, you've undermined what you've set out to do. And you sir have done a knockout job thusfar. From the radical new special effects shots to the subtle additional music, this is shaping up to be the edit to end all edits. I'm sure we all can understand the "real world" issues that take prescedence and will gladly wait however long it takes for this project to be completed.

A couple of suggestion, if I may:

-There was the idea (I believe it was ErikStormtrooper's) in the Starkiller Ranch thread that the 2nd Death Star was in construction over Mustafar. I that case I disagreed, as in its condition above Endor I didn't think it would be going anywhere. That said, if you're going to use a planet in the background of the DS1's into, why not Mustafar? The only drawback there I could see would be a lack of available "background plates" for the lava planet.

-While the "Imperial March" is an essential piece to be included, what do you think about retaining ANH's "Imperial Theme" througout the saga as the "Death Star Theme"? This way you could keep the ANH theme in the films, and mix up the music of the Empire a bit, as you wouldn't want to overplay the March.