logo Sign In

Post #251548

Author
Tiptup
Parent topic
The Lord of the Rings (Films vs. the Books)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/251548/action/topic#251548
Date created
16-Oct-2006, 9:14 AM
Originally posted by: THX
[interweb mode]

Book-accurate movies of LOTR would have been: a) far less successful; b) worse. Criticizing a film adaptation because it's different from the book is senseless.

[/interweb mode]


[answering unsupported statements mode]

Book-accurate movies of LOTR would have been a) far more successful; b) amazingly superior. Criticizing a film adaptation because it is different from the books can often make a lot of sense in many situations.

[/answering unsupported statements mode]