I'm not refuting what you're saying. What I'm saying is that because the Jedi only know of this power, it seems reasonable that Anakin would return as he once was...the Jedi we and his commrades knew. The moral of Anakin's arc, I feel, isn't diminshed by choosing one Anakin over another. He's still Anakin. But to take your place, along side other Jedi in the netherworld of the Force, I think it's reasonable to see Anakin as he once was....
I'm not refuting what you're saying. What I'm saying is that because the Jedi only know of this power, it seems reasonable that Anakin would return as he once was...the Jedi we and his commrades knew. The moral of Anakin's arc, I feel, isn't diminshed by choosing one Anakin over another. He's still Anakin. But to take your place, along side other Jedi in the netherworld of the Force, I think it's reasonable to see Anakin as he once was....