logo Sign In

Post #248941

Author
C3PX
Parent topic
Star Wars prequel film noir (* unfinished project *)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/248941/action/topic#248941
Date created
1-Oct-2006, 6:05 PM
Originally posted by: Trooperman
Only then could we possibly show him killing the children.


I still don't know about the children killing scene, even if it is only implied and not shown I think it was in bad taste that George ever put that in their. Especially when you consider the childish roots this is coming from with Episode I's Jar jar. I really don't think the children killing scene would have appeared in a 40s or 50s noir film.

I was wondering if you had anything in mind about the Chancellor/Palpatine/Sith Lord. How are you going to work out the whole force lightning messed up face thing? I really think george was heading in the right direction in Episode two where he had him looking really old, it would make sense that if he were a very old man in ROTS that 20 years later he would look nearly like a walking corps. I think he should either have the messed up face to start with, or he should remain with a normal face. However, I am not sure if this could be possible, because there is good footage of his looking both ways. For instance the Mace killing scene he has the messed up face, and in the Christopher Lee killing scene he is normal. And I think you are right in saying that that is the perfect Jedi killing scene. I wish it wasn't the only good one. Mace's death is pretty pathetic. I also really like the idea of no Yoda until ESB.