Looks dumb. Unconvincing and illogical. I've also seen an edit that has a ROTS flashback in the emperors lightning attack during ROTJ that is equally stupid. People need to stop believing that because they pirated a copy of Final Cut that they have an talent. Don't put Qui Gon in ROTJ, at least Hayden has a shred of relevance.

People need to stop this desperate attempt to tie the trilogies together. These desperate attempts exist because the PT were so poorly made that the two trilogies don't link up on their own merits; fiddling just makes things worse. Accept that the PT is lousy and move on.