Originally posted by: CO
but I think many from your side just don't understand that the reason many of us don't love the PT movies is because they are not great movies, plain & simple. I think the debates about all the details we discuss, and there are countless of them from the PT, are just a sideshow or a mask for the real reason we don't love them.
but I think many from your side just don't understand that the reason many of us don't love the PT movies is because they are not great movies, plain & simple. I think the debates about all the details we discuss, and there are countless of them from the PT, are just a sideshow or a mask for the real reason we don't love them.
Precisely. The details don't matter. To me, and many others, the P.T. films are simply NOT GOOD MOVIES. That's all there is to it. It's not one detail or another, it's that they simply suck (not to put too fine a point on it).
It's been nice reading what fans of the P.T. appreciate about it. I'm glad those folks can get those positive things out of the movies, and I even understand that a great many of those things are supposed to be "gotten." But I don't get them, and I know I'm hardly alone in my assessment of the prequels. Still, it's all a matter of personal opinion. And mine is that those films are terrible movies.
.