I had a total blast seeing all the new things to the saga, and I still say nothing has been contradicted, which is a collosal feat unto itself when you think about how many years he made these movies over.
So many times have I heard people tell me the reasons they didn't like the PT were because: The directing, writing, acting, and CG sucked.
Then if I ask someone what writing or acting sucked, they list a quote like how Anakin talks about sand.
I ask again, Why? what's wrong with that? and they look at me like: "Well don't you know? It just sucks" there is no "why"!.