logo Sign In

Post #245041

Author
boris
Parent topic
The Official Release VS. EditDroid
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/245041/action/topic#245041
Date created
16-Sep-2006, 10:00 PM
Originally posted by: Darth Mallwalker
Apples & oranges there.
That GOUT shot doesn't come from the laserdisc mastertape like the rest of the movie does. So? It's still a valid comparison as it's part of the DVD.
Originally posted by: Cable-X1
The official release is sharper and more clear than EditDroid, but there is a TON of grain.
Did you actuaqlly watch the official release, or are you commenting from screencaps?Originally posted by: zombie84
A closer comparison is perhaps Moth3r's version, which is practically identical to the GOUT (which is more or less the same sharpness, though less vibrant, but also less grainy as well).
There's only a couple of scenes where Moth3r's seems to have the edge on detail... but with it comes it Moth3r's comes with the price of colour and noise and ghosting ... all of which are better on the official version.