The official disk blows away the Editdroid disk. Its many, many times sharper and has tons more colour fidelity. The only thing it has over the ED version thats bad is the grain, but even the ED looks cleaner simply because the detail gets smudged away. The GOUT is abnormally grainey but this versus the ED versions, the GOUT wins without a second thought. A closer comparison is perhaps Moth3r's version, which is practically identical to the GOUT (which is more or less the same sharpness, though less vibrant, but also less grainy as well).