"This is not the main feature we are talking about here, it's just a bonus feature that gives fans an idea of how much better the films have gotten over time." - Go-Mer Tonic
In this link, Gomer goes through very single ANH change, and explains why they are better.
And, of course, my favorites:
"Because the prequels are better made than the classic trilogy, it becomes much more obvious."
"I hope that Lucas has the gumption to realize he should re-shoot the classic trilogy to bring it up to the high water mark of quality set by the prequels so far. If he doesn't do that, then I fear the classic trilogy will at best, be remembered as "that mediocre sequel to one of the best trilogies of all time."
"Okay, I am just kidding!
To tell you the truth, I like the classic trilogy as much as the prequels. I was just trying to show how anyone can be let down by anything if they put their minds to it."
It is interesting to see people read the first page and then return a nearly identical argurment in the reverse. It's poetic.
You can have the pre-SE classic trilogy. I'm happy with the whole saga the way it is and don't think it needs to be anything more than it is.
Hawk I merely took two of your posts and replaced CT stuff with PT stuff. I don't mean any condescention towards you. I am just showing you how you can make the same arguments against the Classic Trilogy.
In all honesty, I am not kidding on this point.
I am trying to be as realistic as possible when satiring the criticism that has been slung at the prequels since they have been made available.
The classic trilogy is dead. Long live the complete Saga!
The prequels only have to be as good as the classic trilogy. The classic trilogy is widely considered a classic, and the prequels simply complete that classic story.
"If you refer to my "Is the classic trilogy dragging down the overal quality of the SW saga?" thread, I am not being serious there. I am just showing how one could be just as whiney about the classic trilogy as a lot of people are about the prequels.
I stick to my character in that thread. It wouldn't work if I didn't.
I am not saying the OT is bad, I am just saying the prequels are as good.
But even if Lucas just keeps the classic trilogy as bad as it is
In this link, Gomer goes through very single ANH change, and explains why they are better.
Oh you know, just out there representing the SW fans who still think George Lucas is a genius. cool
...and thinking of you.
I will not betray Lucasfilm. My loyalty is with George Lucas, the Jedi Council forums, and with you.LINK
...and thinking of you.
I will not betray Lucasfilm. My loyalty is with George Lucas, the Jedi Council forums, and with you.LINK
And, of course, my favorites:
"Because the prequels are better made than the classic trilogy, it becomes much more obvious."
"I hope that Lucas has the gumption to realize he should re-shoot the classic trilogy to bring it up to the high water mark of quality set by the prequels so far. If he doesn't do that, then I fear the classic trilogy will at best, be remembered as "that mediocre sequel to one of the best trilogies of all time."
"Okay, I am just kidding!
To tell you the truth, I like the classic trilogy as much as the prequels. I was just trying to show how anyone can be let down by anything if they put their minds to it."
It is interesting to see people read the first page and then return a nearly identical argurment in the reverse. It's poetic.
You can have the pre-SE classic trilogy. I'm happy with the whole saga the way it is and don't think it needs to be anything more than it is.
Hawk I merely took two of your posts and replaced CT stuff with PT stuff. I don't mean any condescention towards you. I am just showing you how you can make the same arguments against the Classic Trilogy.
In all honesty, I am not kidding on this point.
I am trying to be as realistic as possible when satiring the criticism that has been slung at the prequels since they have been made available.
The classic trilogy is dead. Long live the complete Saga!
The prequels only have to be as good as the classic trilogy. The classic trilogy is widely considered a classic, and the prequels simply complete that classic story.
"If you refer to my "Is the classic trilogy dragging down the overal quality of the SW saga?" thread, I am not being serious there. I am just showing how one could be just as whiney about the classic trilogy as a lot of people are about the prequels.
I stick to my character in that thread. It wouldn't work if I didn't.
I am not saying the OT is bad, I am just saying the prequels are as good.
But even if Lucas just keeps the classic trilogy as bad as it is
Notice the third to the last one. That's classic Gomer. I was more than happy to give these to the TF.n mods at the time, as they were getting ready to ban his ass for this kind of nonsense. Obviously, he's not stopped - neither there or here.