logo Sign In

Post #244064

Author
Zion
Parent topic
Star Wars Limited Edition Screen Captures.
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/244064/action/topic#244064
Date created
14-Sep-2006, 11:11 AM
Originally posted by: Moth3r
This is weird. Although the GOUT version has more horizontal detail, it looks like vertical detail has been filtered. Compare the width of the black line in shot 4:

http://img96.imageshack.us/img96/3729/untitled1copyyc7.jpg

(GOUT - top, Moth3r - bottom. The increase in grain is also evident in this shot.)

So - is this loss of vertical because of the upscaling from NTSC to PAL? Please can somebody grab some comparison frames from the NTSC release?


I think before we start throwing ideas around llike detail has been lost or they added grain, we need to compare the GOUT to the NTSC Definitive Collection LD, which all versions of the GOUT look to be sourced from. It's one thing to compare it to a PAL transfer or a pre-'93 transfer, and completely another to compare it to the version it actually came from. When I have time tonight or tomarrow I'll post screenshots of a DC capture, unless someone beats me to it. (hint )

And THX, you are the MAN!