logo Sign In

Post #243635

Author
mverta
Parent topic
First Impressions of the OOT ...
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/243635/action/topic#243635
Date created
13-Sep-2006, 11:59 AM
http://www.mikeverta.com/Posts/SW_Compare_1a.png

On the left, a pre-93 laserdisc image. On the right, the 2006 "1993-laserdisc-master" DVD. The image is grainier. This either means that the '93 laserdiscs were sourced from a different, and grainier print than the pre-'93 laserdiscs, which would mean they went through the re-issuing and quality actually went down in some respects, or this image has been artificially grained-up. There are some other differences in the images to suggest a different print, as well, so it's not 100% clear. The comment "mixed bag" is especially appropriate to describe the 2006 DVD, which is why I said I'd bet money, and not that I was definitively sure. Having done grain matching on more than 100 projects in the last 10 years, I see a good amount of evidence for post-added grain, which has a look you can recognize if you're familiar enough with it. Ditto the digital gate-weave added to the recreated crawl - it's very distinctive, and easily recognizable. This is a compelling compare; judge for yourself.

That being said...

JediRandy: When you're aware of my credentials and restoration expertise, I'll gladly welcome your input, sans personal attacks. But not before.


_Mike