logo Sign In

Post #243567

Author
Moth3r
Parent topic
Are the PAL GOUT DVDs upscaled from the NTSC masters?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/243567/action/topic#243567
Date created
13-Sep-2006, 6:13 AM
From a screenshot comparison, it appears that the PAL discs are definitley from the same master used for the NTSC laserdiscs.

However, it does seem that the DVDs do contain more picture detail than my transfers - I think screenshots I'd seen previously had been softened and did not accurately represent the quality of the DVD.

(Which is what you'd expect, as the transfer process:
D1 master -> DVD
is theoretically superior to:
D1 master -> Laserdisc -> Analogue capture -> DVD)

But the transfer process has also reproduced a fair amount of grain and noise. I'm sort of leaning towards processing the GOUT DVD for Moth3r V1.1 rather than a new laserdisc transfer, using a filter chain to remove noise and convert the image to anamorphic.

My ultimate dream for V2.0 would use colour-corrected shots from the 2004 version (which have been cleaned up without that damn ghosting), and only use the GOUT version where necessary. A sort of ultimate classic edition, if you like.