I just bought the Best Buy tin, and it's very nice. It does hold all 3 DVD cases (it's much thicker than in the photo) and it opens on both sides. $59.99 vs. $16.99 for each DVD, so the case ends up being $9.00. I haven't watched the discs yet....I went out at lunchtime to get it and I was worried they'd all be gone, but the store had plenty, and they weren't very busy. I think they'll be busier tonight when people get off work. They have a 4-sided display right as you walk in with the tins, the DVD singles and the new Lego game.