logo Sign In

Post #240453

Author
Obi Jeewhyen
Parent topic
What movies do you consider canon?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/240453/action/topic#240453
Date created
1-Sep-2006, 4:42 PM
Originally posted by: SKot
My personal list below ...
SEMI-CANON ...
Star Wars - the Jabba & Han scene (maybe if it was Jabba's henchman instead of Jabba himself)

But how would this be any different from the Greedo scene? How is it different whether it's Jabba or a henchalien? The same exact information, with nothing new, as presented by Greedo in the Cantina. Hence why this scene is redundant. Hence why a good director would have left it on the cutting room floor, and not for the reason of effects technology limitations.

(Sorry, this scene is one of my peeviest pet peeves about the revisions to Star Wars. Rightful editing room rejects brought back to life just gets my goat, or starwars duck, or whatever animal makes a mad, growling sound)




This is not meant to derail, or to criticize anyone's personal canon choices.

.