That was exactly what I was thinking when Lucas said he wanted to "update" the OT. I figured we'd get three movies that were still the same, but with updated SFX shots that fit right into the movie in terms of time and in terms of keeping with the sound and music tracks. That way we'd get three almost brand new movies, but they would still be the same. I figured Lucas would digitally restore the OT, then do this awesome magic and then then do the prequels from there. That way, all the movies would have basically fit together in SFX looks.
Lucas dropped the ball big time on an opportunity to re-insert himself into the movie world with those special editions. Instead, he hacked the movies up, made them look like shit and alienated a lot of fans in the process. Well....the man's crazy, so what do you expect.
As for Trek...the SFX from that mirror episode of Enterprise were awesome. The original series starship in that one looked majestic, I swear. I'm open to updating the SFX, but just the SFX....leave the actor's footage alone....just do the spaceship shots. But, as I said....I'm open to it. I can't say I'll like it. Personally, I say leave it the hell alone...but I wouldn't mind seeing it either. I say do one episode and then do a special broadcast of it. Then see what the reaction is.