I actually have that capture device and I think it gives a very good capture from analog video. The only problem I have is dropped frames but I'm not sure of the cause of that, it could be the computer or the card. Other than that, I get great captures, even from vhs. I think it's very hard to tell the difference between playing the Hi8 tape directly to my tv and the dvd made from the captures. I have some screen caps but I don't know how to post them online.