I absolutely agree on Signs. it was a religious movie about fate and faith, not an Alien invasion movie. The Aliens were jsut the addition to it to give this a context. I love Signs the way it is.
And I think we did work pretty well together and without you our WOTW would not have been what it later on was. You had plenty of really good ideas, btu there we are in the true world of film business. The final decision is to the producer. I know there are things about this edit that bother me and most of it is quality based, I am not satisfied with the transitions in the cellar, I don't like the colours from Deep Impact and those stupid interlacing and deinterlacing problems... But I never bothered about the subtitles. I see the problem more in the change of perspective. My ending moves away from Ray, but the movie was with him for the entire time. This causes a serious break IMHO. Unfortunately I had no more scenes with Ray, which I could use.
IRANTANPLAN, it sounds as if you want to make a fanedit of a fanedit...hehe.. I guess that has never been done before, But I am proud if our project was the inspiration for that.