All I will say is I don't know why everybody likes the Biggs scene. In the last part of the 4th act, you do not add a new character ... and it's stupid to slow down the rapidly ramping-up action of battle readiness. The change in pacing to this importantly-paced part of the film makes this addition lame in my view.

Oh, and getting rid of Yub-Nub? Sorry, but sacrilege. Dropping Lapti Nek may have been the most ruinous of a formerly good scene, but nixing Yub-Nub was just plain WRONG.

Those are the areas in which I appear to disagree with most fans. I'm right on target with every other popular like and dislike, though.