logo Sign In

Post #234307

Author
Mike O
Parent topic
Expecting too much of George Lucas?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/234307/action/topic#234307
Date created
11-Aug-2006, 11:23 PM

While still not worthy of hatred, George should be heavily criticized as a person over these moves.

I'm more inclined to criticize the actions than the man.

. Even worse is the way he prevents the original form of the movies from ever being seen and that’s an unforgivable course of action so long as he decides to stick to it.

That is crititicism he deserves.

Besides, I may be one of the few people old enough to get Gaffer Tape's screen name. (She was amazingly beautiful when she was young)


Whom?

As part of the saga, I've come to appreciate Empire a bit, but I find it totally unworkable as its own single film.


Yes, but that's the whole point. ESB gets what it is: a part of the whole. Part of the problem with is that ROTJ doesn't entirely lead it to a satifyng concllusion ins many peoples's eyes, which probably weakens ESB. ESB is superbly crafted, saga or not, which, while I enjoy the PT, is not a complement that I can give it.