I think the list is pretty valid. You see, what bothers me is the fact that 36.7% of the people on that site gave it a 10!? How could they? They movie was littered with plot holes and poor tie-ins to the OOT. Plus the acting was terrible, the story was contrived and stupid, and the CGI looked terrible and there was tons of pointless characters (General Grevious) and poor pacing.