logo Sign In

STAR WARS - Enhanced HD & O-OT HD Packs... some suggestions... — Page 2

Author
Time
I hate that damn Yoda/Dooku duel (even the Palpatine one). Whatever happened to "Maser Yoda"? Whatever happened to "war does not make one great"? Why was he denigrated to a flipping hamster on a treadwheel?
Author
Time
I don't think the OT needs to be altered to fit the PT. It should be the other way around. Or, better yet, the PT should be thrown out and redone by someone with talent.
Author
Time
Im betting that after 2007, Lucas will insist that the OT was meant to be seen in 3-d, and thus we will get blu rays with the obscenely changed 3-d super special edition- i dont want to know how bad the quality of a HD OOT will be come 2015. (based on the current treds)
Author
Time
I dont understand why this 3-D crap. Surely the little nutjob is out of his mind for planning (let alone suggesting) such a thing.
Author
Time
Originally posted by: SpecialEditionSaboteur
I hate that damn Yoda/Dooku duel (even the Palpatine one). Whatever happened to "Maser Yoda"? Whatever happened to "war does not make one great"? Why was he denigrated to a flipping hamster on a treadwheel?


Author
Time
Damn it, I just finished a post and when I hit submit it suddenly all disappeared.

I agree with SES above wholeheartedly. If that scene had to be shot at all, then I think it should have been more like this: Dooku tries to attack Yoda. Yoda sighs and just holds out his hand, palm out. Dooku gets stopped short. Then out comes Yoda's lightsaber all by itself and, while Yoda just stands there eyes closed, his lightsaber does all the duelling. Surely it would be much more in character (and much more super cool) for Yoda to just stand there and whip Dooku's arse using just the force.
Author
Time
I'm not sure why a Jedi Master would need a Lightsaber at all--especially one as powerful as Yoda.
Author
Time
Originally posted by: Nanner Split - He can add in a five minute scene of Han Solo taking a shit aboard the Millenium Falcon for all I care...


Luca$h: "I just wanted to take people further into the Universe that I created all on my own, by myself, with nobody's help at all, ever.

I just thought to myself, in an all too frequent flash of genius, that we never see people defaecating in my stories. I decided that this left a big hole in the 'Star Wars Experience' (TM)!

So, I revisited all of the movies and have edited in CG-doubles for all the characters to show them at that most private of moments, so that we can all see how it happens! I'm particularly proud of the scene in 'The Phantom Menace', where I have Qui-Gon Jinn squatting over a midden in Mos Eisley, reading 'Funny Quotes The Senators Thought We Forgot!'"
Don't you call me a mindless philosopher...!
Author
Time
Originally posted by: bbbb
If this guy wants to do that, go ahead. Post it on the net when you can and we'll watch it. I think George Lucas is gearing up to 'pass the torch' anyway. He's in his fifties or sixties now and why would he change the original trilogy again? He's only done it what, 2 - maybe 3 times?

I Believe that he is making more changes for the 2007 set.

The CGI Gollum from LOTR looks more realistic than that Yoda. Its funny how Luca$h always wants the SW movies to be the most technologically sophisticated films on the planet, but the PT doesn't even surpass the effects work of a low budget Ray Harryhausen film (which are superb by the way).


I agree wholeheartedly on both counts. Plus, Gollum was an actual character with a complete backstory who interacted with others, developed, and existed to serve the narrative. Harryhausen's work may look dated now, but now only does it have soul and imaginative verve, like original OOT effects did.

“What Orwell feared were those who would ban books. What Huxley feared was that there would be no reason to ban a book, for there would be no one who wanted to read one.”

Neil Postman, Amusing Ourselves to Death

Author
Time
Originally posted by: auraloffalwaffle
Originally posted by: Nanner Split - He can add in a five minute scene of Han Solo taking a shit aboard the Millenium Falcon for all I care...


Luca$h: "I just wanted to take people further into the Universe that I created all on my own, by myself, with nobody's help at all, ever.

I just thought to myself, in an all too frequent flash of genius, that we never see people defaecating in my stories. I decided that this left a big hole in the 'Star Wars Experience' (TM)!

So, I revisited all of the movies and have edited in CG-doubles for all the characters to show them at that most private of moments, so that we can all see how it happens! I'm particularly proud of the scene in 'The Phantom Menace', where I have Qui-Gon Jinn squatting over a midden in Mos Eisley, reading 'Funny Quotes The Senators Thought We Forgot!'"


Does that mean sometime in the future we'll finally be able to see a hardcore porn scene between Slave Leia and Jabba the Hutt?

Author
Time
Originally posted by: SpecialEditionSaboteur - Does that mean sometime in the future we'll finally be able to see a hardcore porn scene between Slave Leia and Jabba the Hutt?


Oh, man! That would have to be the ultimate indignity! Maybe they could shoot the new scenes with Carrie Fisher in 'youthful' make-up and, of course, use CGI stand-ins ('cos that always looks great).

BTW, did anyone else think that Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen looked distinctly effeminate in their make-up at the beginning of X3?
Don't you call me a mindless philosopher...!