I like the SE on DVD by far the best. The only regrettable thing is, as mentioned the Lois Lane poem, but its not all that bad and its brief. But other than that all the additions are fabulous--you get some great extra development on Clarke's home life on the farm that rounds out the characters much more and some great scenes later on including a terrific one of Superman fighting Lex Luthor's machine gun room. I find the extra extended editions that include every deleted scene to become boring but the Special Edition is rightly balanced IMO.