logo Sign In

Post #221702

Author
CO
Parent topic
George ruined the drama in his own stories.
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/221702/action/topic#221702
Date created
25-Jun-2006, 6:06 PM
Raiders of the Lost Ark is the purest form of the 1930's serial type movie that Lucas/Spielberg enjoyed as kids. It was fast, action packed, very well paced, and the characters were explained enough but not too much, or not too fleshed out. All that movie needed was for us to love Indiana Jones, and the rest of the movie was gravy for the Spielberg. That is why it is a classic even today, it is what it is.

SW '77 was in some ways the same way. It had the typical Wizard, Princess, Farmboy, Bad Guy with a mask, and Smartass Rogue character, all stereotypes, that weren't totally explored because of the standalone movie. Both movies work to perfection because they are basic in their fundamentals of movie making and don't try to be anything else. The simpleness of Star Wars is what I love, it doesn't try to show Vader conflicted, it doesn't show too much of each character that would have overidden the basic good vs evil story.

ESB is much more than that, and that is why it is great. It takes everything in SW '77 and delves deep into every character, but does it in a adult way where it doesnt come off as laughable. The PT and some respects ROTJ tries to be like SW '77/Raiders in telling a story that is a roller coaster ride for 2 hours, but tries to delve deep into a character like Anakin/Padme/Vader and what drives them to what they do, but those two styles don't mix.

Look at every Anakin/Padme dramatic scene in the PT, it comes as laughable every time, because the serial style of movie is not meant to be a character piece, it is a macro story-type movie just like SW '77/Raiders where if you like the characters, you're hooked. That is why many fans like myself can still watch the PT for the popcorn entertainment of them for 2 hours, but laugh everytime they try to get dramatic to give it that emotional weight ESB had. The problem is it is laughable, and it aint a comedy.