I will agree with everything you said about The Sixth Sense, save for the idea that Pay It Forward was a good film (I'm sorry, but that movie came across as the biggest piece of self-righteous crap I've ever seen. Just my opinion, of course). Unbreakable did nothing for me. And, yes, anytime the aliens were not visibly appearing in Signs (except in silhouette or at a great distance; I hated the living room scene and the TV news footage) was pretty good. So I guess I can't really badmouth that one too much. I don't think there was a single bit about The Village that I really liked at all. Well, maybe Bryce Dallas Howard; she played blind very convincingly.