I actually prefer the movie version to the stage musical (gasp!). The revelation of the Phantom's past, the swordfight, the new "Don Juan," and the flashbacks (or flash forwards?) were all nice additions that enhanced the film. Also, I have nothing against the film soundtrack either (gasp!). Michael Crawford is excellent, no doubt about it, but Gerard Butler brings something new to the role, and I like his different approach. I don't understand why so many Phantom fans are down on the movie. I think it was great and am happy to have it in my collection. That said, I look forward to securing a copy of this very interesting project.