Originally posted by: greencapt
I am all for extras but don't want to buy 3 or 4 versions of a film to get one that I actually want to view.

I equate this 4-versions-in-1 BR release to the Dawn of the Dead Ultimate Edition set. I bought that not because I wanted the European cut, or the extended cut, or the theatrical cut. I'll typically watch the theatrical cut anyway. I bought it so I could have the choice. Which is exactly why I'll buy this BR set. I understand your point of view, but don't equate this to Lucas - he's still giving you a choice. Granted, you do have to get all the other versions at the same time to get the one you want, but isn't that better than not getting it at all?