logo Sign In

My Response

Author
Time
This will be THE WORST selling Star Wars video release in your history. You took what should have been the only worthy reason for any fan to buy them, again, and turned it into the reason the fans are now sharpening their pitchforks. With a very small amount of effort and money, you could have had a DVD set that would have probably sold BETTER than the '04 box sets. Now you have a DVD with NO selling points at all. These same Special Edition DVD's have been on the shelf for two years or more now in the boxed sets everyone and their grandmother has bought already. Mr. Joe Average doesn't care about the 'unaltered' versions. The only people who cared about having the films on DVD as they appeared in the 70's-80's were the die-hard fans. Now THEY aren't going to buy them either because you decided to take the cheap and easy route and try to screw us out of even more money for something you put ZERO effort into! Nice work!

As for the LIE that the necessary elements do not exist anymore, they are just that, lies. The elements DO exist for this to happen in the way it should. Go to www.thedigitalbits.com and see. There are people just waiting to make a high quality anamorphic DVD transfer a reality. The elements may not exist at the Lucasfilm vaults, but, seemingly OTHERS had more foresight and respect for film history. Swallow your pride and ask to borrow them, for gods sake. Star Wars is Star Wars. It set the standard for quality in 1977 and it still did all the way up to 'Revenge of the Sith'. Whatever Mr. Lucas feels about which version best represents his 'vision', no version of any Star Wars film should ever exist on DVD in less than standard quality. Ever.

The utter disdain for the fans wishes seems especially callous and disrespectful after so many years. Mr. Lucas may have made the films, but WE made them successful. After 10 years of hoping, pleading, and begging, trying to throw us a bone with a pathetic little bootleg-quality POS is not going to cut it. We dont want a ultra, pristine, super high-quality 'restoration'. We are only asking for the original films, unaltered, with industry STANDARD mastering. Why would you even consider any less?? Have you so little respect for us? That, I think, is all we can infer from this situation. We give you money and you treat us like garbage. Well, no longer. I think it is safe to say that this is the straw that broke the camels back. The nail in the coffin. I plan on spending all the time I can from now till the day these come out letting people know what a sad slap in the face this is. I will be there at Best Buy the night before. Not lining up to buy them with all the other fans as I would like to be, but to spread the word that they should not bother spending their hard earned cash on something so worthless. I will have handbills, signs, buttons, anything I can think of to ensure that you dont sell any copies of this travesty. I never thought the day would come when I would encourage other fans NOT to buy something to do with Star Wars.

However, it is not too late. (I hope). You still have time to salvage some of your fanbase and your, (once), good name. I will beg one last time. Please, PLEASE take the time to make this right! You could make this DVD one long remembered. This is really your ultimate opportunity. If you did this right you could coast easily right into Geek history. Disc one: The Lowry-scrubbed anamorphic '04 edition, digitally sparkling and brilliant, and, Disc two: The rough but ready theatrical versions, anamorphic, in all their matte lined glory. These could be the ultimate Star Wars DVD's. These SHOULD be the ultimate Star Wars DVD's. Please, for the love of god, dont blow it!

Otherwise, Thanks for nothing,

Nathan Harbaugh



--I just sent this to Lynne Hale, I thought I'd share. PLEASE DO THE SAME, ITS NOT TOO LATE, DONT GIVE UP THE FIGHT!!!!!!!!!
“We like to think that we are very particular, because we’ve done about a hundred movies now, and we strive to make our output pristine. So to work with a guy like Lucas is fabulous because he’s got his head in the same place, pristine.”
Author
Time
I think your wrong, this will not be the worst selling star wars dvd in history.
Author
Time
you are absolutely right Obiwampa, I rather have my VHS die than get this release.
Author
Time
Eros, dont come in here to start s**t. I've read posts by you elsewhere, and I'm really not interested in hearing it here. Either you are part of the solution or you are part of the problem, quit being part of the problem and get out. Ass.
“We like to think that we are very particular, because we’ve done about a hundred movies now, and we strive to make our output pristine. So to work with a guy like Lucas is fabulous because he’s got his head in the same place, pristine.”
Author
Time
You might want to take some of that "more flies with honey than vinegar" to heart.

I'm just saying.
Author
Time
It might not be that constructive to say that Mr. Joe Average won't be buying this, and that it only a pplies ( I mean applies, my backspace key isn't working) to a niche market. This is tu, er, true to an extent, but there's no need to make them think there isn't too much of an audience fo rthis. There might be more interested in it htan you think.

There is no lingerie in space…

C3PX said: Gaffer is like that hot girl in high school that you think you have a chance with even though she is way out of your league because she is sweet and not a stuck up bitch who pretends you don’t exist… then one day you spot her making out with some skinny twerp, only on second glance you realize it is the goth girl who always sits in the back of class; at that moment it dawns on you why she is never seen hanging off the arm of any of the jocks… and you realize, damn, she really is unobtainable after all. Not that that is going to stop you from dreaming… Only in this case, Gaffer is actually a guy.

Author
Time
Originally posted by: Obiwampa
Eros, dont come in here to start s**t. I've read posts by you elsewhere, and I'm really not interested in hearing it here. Either you are part of the solution or you are part of the problem, quit being part of the problem and get out. Ass.


I don't mean to take sides but there's no need to be hypocritical, Obiwampa.
http://www.my-musik.com/uploads/zidane006.gif