It could be something as simple as "We all might disagree on the details, but there is one thing we all want, an anamorphic transfer from film, not from a 1993 video master (with detail sapping digital video noise reduction like on the THX laserdsics)"
Maybe if we can get a single coherent message through it might have a chance, if anyone read all the various forums and focussed on the different things everyone wants (rather than on what they have in common) then they would throw their hands up and cry that "we can never satisfy these people at all, so why try too hard, they will all hate it whatever we do"
This way, maybe at least if they got the core right, we could do the rest ourselves, if they get the core wrong, we are no better off than we are now.